Home | Archive

Preludes

🌱 tags: inkhaven updated: , , , ,

Game night

Imagine it's board game night. You and your friends want to play a game. But you don't yet know which.

As may happen in some circles, someone says, "Wait. Why don't we make a game out of picking the game? We'll take turns picking. Rock-paper-scissors to determine turn order."

As may happen in some circles, your first player says, "let's play the game-picking game! Same turn order as the above."

This is deemed hilarious, roundly praised as a grand joke.

After a few rounds of selecting the game-picking game, a real game gets chosen.

What is a "real" game? Why?

Hypergame

Hypergame is a mathematical puzzle first described by Zwicker1 to a class of students as a riff on an old exam bonus question: define hypergame as a game where the first choice is the choice of finite game to play. All finite games are allowed. Is "hypergame" a finite game? Can it be chosen?

The Zwicker paper shows us how hypergame is a variant of the Burali-Forti paradox, which loosely says that the ordinal numbers can't form a set on pain of antinomy. Choosing is also counting, you see: each turn bumps the counter.

If we chose to play hypergame forever, hypergame would never end. That means it isn't a finite game at all, and shouldn't have been among the choices.

So if we eliminate "hypergame" from the choices of game in hypergame, do we make it finite? Russell's paradox style?

It does not: you've just built hypergame-prime, which is "hypergame except you can't choose 'hypergame'", which is now a choice of game in hypergame-prime.

There: now I've given you a plausible-enough just-so story, and derived from it a contrived spherical cow. High-decouplers rejoice.2 You are never leaving game night again.

Social choice functions

You know that old adage that "there's enough food in the world for nobody to go hungry – it's just a matter of distribution?"

Let's try to solve a piece of that here.

Abstract away, if you will, the challenges of getting everything everywhere; imagine an Oracle that will fulfill any distribution of resources you choose, just as soon as you can manage to all choose it. One time, one wish. Rezone the farms, earmark the grocery bags, end to end.

Any function that solves for this is called a social choice function. If performed in the style we were all excited about back in the 30s and 40s, it would be a Bergson-Samuelson social welfare function.

Anyway, we can't write these. Or, well, we can, but we won't all ratify them. Or, well, maybe we will, but if

  • We're trying to make sure that we make all choices that would make everybody happier, i.e. nobody's forgetting ethical chocolate while ethical chocolate's on the cards.
  • We're trying to write an allocation of everything we can; we must know what to do with the Nesquik and the durian alike. No exclusions.
  • Relatedly: we're trying not to flip how apples are allocated relative to oranges when we try to introduce the question of how to allocate bananas. This is finicky and horrible but can you think of a better way to update the function without getting Dutch-booked by a bad actor? Remember that we all have to ratify this.3
  • No one person is calling all the shots. No dictators.

Well, we can't. No such function exists.4, 5

Ranked choice voting

You watch Alaska's 2026 midterms with breathless envy. If only, you think, I could vote under a system this good. If only I could vote five times on one ballot. If only I could watch myself converse with ten thousand others – or a hundred million, or two billion – as our second preferences were considered, when our first failed the test of naive consensus. First-past-the-post is a pretty nice way to say my way or the highway. It's a pretty nice way to say my job is not to worry about those people.

There's a system out there, in use today, that does on the merits just seem better.

Locally rational

You go to the market. Tangerines are in season. You weren't craving them before, but now suddenly the dream of a slice, splitting between your teeth, fills your mouth. You replace the orange juice on the shelf from your basket. Five minutes ago, you were debating whether you needed the chocolate really, but now the chocolate can stay.

Tonight's dessert is taking shape in your mind as you cross to the checkout, humming.

T.S.

I

The winter evening settles down
With smell of steaks in passageways.
Six o’clock.
The burnt-out ends of smoky days.
And now a gusty shower wraps
The grimy scraps
Of withered leaves about your feet
And newspapers from vacant lots;
The showers beat
On broken blinds and chimney-pots,
And at the corner of the street
A lonely cab-horse steams and stamps.

And then the lighting of the lamps.

— T.S. Eliot

Footnotes:

1

Zwicker (1987-06) Playing Games with Games: The Hypergame Paradox, Am. Math. Monthly, http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2322840 (my note).

2

this double negative really bothers me. I get that it's pointing at the positive action of decoupling, not the negative space where coupling ought to be, but you must notice the pejorative connotations and how the unnecessary involution smacks of copium to an uninitiated ear – forgive me, never mind, I presume that was out of scope for the coinage.

3

Debate rages on how to construct this axiom; what constraints do you want to place on your add-alternative operation, and what for? What failure modes are you trying to protect against? What does your spherical cow need to do in your model?(Maskin (2025-02) Borda’s Rule and Arrow’s Independence Condition, Journal of Political Economy, https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/732892) Fortunately for me this is only a prelude.

4

Arrow, Sen & Suzumura (2010) Handbook of Social Choice and Welfare, Elsevier, .

5

In the interest of clarity, the point I am trying to make (or, well, prefigure) is in fact about model utility. (alyssavance (2009-10-24T20:46:07) Arrow’s Theorem Is a Lie, , https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/hqpSutKLfBQtffs72/arrow-s-theorem-is-a-lie) is a much better and clearer treatment of this exact case than mine. Please go read it.